NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - Call it the fat tax: Extra weight can
lighten your wallet in many ways, including higher out-of-pocket
medical expenses, higher insurance premiums, and -- according to
some studies -- lower salaries.
Add it all up and the average overweight American pays through
the nose for extra pounds on the hips.
The medical cost mess
There's a long list of medical ailments associated with excess
weight in several categories:
- Metabolic complications including type 2 diabetes,
hypertension, gallstones, fatty liver disease, gout, and sleep
apnea;
- Degenerative conditions such as arthritis, angina and stroke;
- Anatomic complications such as hernias, blood clots, urinary
incontinence and skin ulcers;
- Six types of cancer.
No wonder overweight Americans also suffer depression more often
than average.
Treating these conditions adds an estimated $93 billion a year to
medical spending (half of which the government bears), according to
Eric Finkelstein, one of the authors of a national study on medical
costs of obesity paid for by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control.
That surpasses health care costs generated by smoking. "Obesity
is the nation's number one public health problem," Finkelstein says.
Medical costs are passed along to all Americans in the form of
Medicare and Medicaid funding and contributions to group medical
plans.
But overweight people needing private coverage may have to pay
increased premiums, according to Phil Supple, spokesman for State
Farm Insurance.
Life insurance, too, is more expensive for the overweight.
Insurers use ideal weight tables in conjunction with their mortality
figures and base their rates on the results. Supple says that the
cost of coverage goes up incrementally with weight.
Insurers recognize that the average American waistline has grown,
says Alan Hixon, managing consultant for State Farm Insurance. His
company begins to impose a surcharge on life insurance applicants
after "they reach a full 75 percent over ideal body weight," he
says.
|
|
Insurer |
|
Premium for
160-pound male |
|
Premium for
240-pound male |
|
Difference |
|
Protective
Life |
$16.80 |
$22.49 |
34% |
|
Wm Penn of
NY |
$15.06 |
$20.74 |
38% |
|
Zurich Life of
NY |
$15.93 |
$26.63 |
67% | |
|
|
|
That means a 35-year-old non-smoking male, 5 foot 10 inches tall,
whose ideal body weight falls between 148 pounds and 189 pounds can
weigh up to 251 pounds without incurring any extra premium. Once
there he would pay $2.65 annually for every $1,000 in coverage,
about 18 percent more than normal. For other examples see the
accompanying table from Insure.com.
Private health insurance has a similar weight penalty, although
it usually kicks in at a somewhat lower weight.
Jack Walker, the executive director of the state employees health
plan for North Carolina, says that when his organization recently
began doing health-risk appraisals for its members, the breadth of
the problem surprised him.
In one typical county he found that, of the state employees who
opted to have the appraisal, 80 percent qualified as overweight,
including 35 percent who were obese and another 12 percent morbidly
obese.
Who's going to pay for the growing medical bills? The way
insurance works normally, of course, is that healthy members, who
consume fewer medical services, subsidize the unhealthy members of a
group, who consume more.
But the supply of normal-sized people has dried up, and Walker is
worried. "We're at the point where the obese are subsidizing the
very obese," he says.
The poverty penalty
On the job front, the deck is stacked against overweight people.
Rik Kopelan, an executive recruiter for Capstone Partnership,
says employers are "absolutely" less inclined to hire the
overweight. "It has to do with perception of character," he says.
"Employers think, if you are ambitious you wouldn't let yourself get
fat and sloppy."
Once on the job, a glass ceiling may come into play, although
Kopelan says weight discrimination after hiring is less of a
problem; your employer soon learns whether you're capable or not.
The National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance (NAAFA),
however, points out that only one in 11 top male executives is
overweight, an extraordinarily low percentage in a country where
more than two-thirds of the population needs to shed some poundage
and at least 30 percent are classified as obese.
Some academic studies suggest the problem is even more
pronounced, especially for women. "If you're fat, you're more likely
to drift into poverty," says Esther Rothblum, a women's health
expert and psychologist with the University of Vermont.
Her research suggests the overweight get shortchanged on
education -- overweights are often discouraged by teachers, friends,
even parents, from extending their education. Overweight women are
less likely to marry, and when they do they tend to wed men of lower
socio-economic status than themselves. Thinner women marry wealthier
men.
A study by John Cawley, a professor of policy analysis at
Cornell, found that overweight Caucasian women earn 9 percent less
than those with svelte silhouettes. And a University of Michigan
study reported that the total net worth of moderately to severely
obese women falls as much as 60 percent below average.
And women seem to suffer more job discrimination than men.
According to Rothblum, while 40 percent of the overweight men in a
study group she ran reported that they have not received a job they
sought because of their weight, the statistic for women -- 60
percent -- was even more dismal. And how do they know that their
weight disqualified them? The hirers told them.
Says Rothblum: "Americans aren't afraid of saying that they hate
fat people." |